The Appeal

Shaindy - a daughter who has suffered from an angry father her whole life, appeals in a letter to him, begging that he should open up his heart...

3 min

Dr. Zev Ballen

Posted on 05.04.21

My Rebbe, Rabbi Shalom Arush says that one of the most important things that we need to do is to cleanse our hearts from anger. It is easier to hate than to love, so what can we do? Shaindy is someone who feels caught in this dilemma right now.
 
She grew up in a religious home where nothing was real. Her father's constant yelling sapped  the beauty from their lives, and left only the veneer of Judaism in their home and in their hearts.  Nothing that Shaindy did was good enough or fast enough for her father, despite how hard she tried to please him. When she got married, Shaindy felt free for the first time in her life – but now due to circumstances beyond her control, she is once again living in her father's house – only this time with a husband and two children.  Why is G-d doing this? What  good will come from opening  the wounds of her childhood?
 
Dear Father,
 
I want to introduce myself. I am your daughter, Shaindel. I have come back, maybe for the last time to be with you in the house of my youth.  It is very painful for me here, but I'm learning that everything that Hashem does is for my absolute good. So I've asked myself. What possible good is there to hearing you yell and criticize everyone in this house? What good is it that I am acting like you toward my own children? What good is it for me to be feeling so angry and so frightened?
 
I want to share with you what I have learned from speaking to Hashem. It's very important for me to be here now. There are lots of skeletons in my closet. Of all your children, I was the most worried about not hurting you. We were all off the derech (not observant) but I hid it well. Now I'm the angriest of your children. Father, I'm just like you. I want to destroy. I want to ruin. I didn't realize this until recently. I was hiding it from myself – but that's not what Hashem wants. I need to stop hiding. Hashem doesn't  want me to make aliyah now and continue to hide from my problems in Israel. Hashem knows that without you in my life, I would not work on myself. I would not uproot my anger and fix it once and for all. 
 
Father, why do you hate for no reason? My husband's a good man. He believed in me when I didn't believe in myself and married me. He's helped me re-connect to being Jewish. He has taught me about Breslever teachings and the works of Rabbi Shalom Arush. Believe me father, Rav Arush's words are not words from this world, they come from beyond and touch us deeply.  Father, if I were thinking on my own, I wouldn't even try this. If I were relying on my own head I would not do this.  I can only write this, because it's impossible to speak.  Please open your heart, father, and hear what I am going to tell you. I had a vision of what it could be like to live with you in love and peace. I have seen what we could have together without anger and yelling. I can see us in a whole new light – a normal happy family. It might be our last chance.
 
Father, there are hidden parts to us that we feel we must hide from others and ourselves – but we can strengthen those parts. Let me tell you how. Rebbe Nachman teaches that the really important things that we have to learn in life we can only learn through making mistakes. When we "fail" this is the deepest process of learning that there is. We all make mistakes, but there is no mistake in the world that is big enough to ever give up. That's why I can forgive you although my head tells me not to. That's why I can love you although my head tells me not to.  I'm not expecting perfection, just the will to begin. I hope that you'll open your heart to what I've said. We are one family. We are one people. There is one G-d. We are here to be partners with Hashem and to fix His world. This is what I have learned, my dear father. It's never too late.
 
May It Be So.

Tell us what you think!

Thank you for your comment!

It will be published after approval by the Editor.

Add a Comment